Justin Lombardoni, the ornamental plant breeder at the Chicago Botanic Garden, used a July appearance at the Perennial Plant Association's National Symposium in East Lansing, Michigan, to explain what sets his program apart from for-profit industry breeders. Speaking in a session where breeders discussed their current work, he said his goal was to describe how a nonprofit botanic garden targets genera and traits differently. To his knowledge, the Chicago Botanic Garden runs the only breeding program housed at a botanic garden in the country.
Prioritizing natives, defined by region
When choosing which genera to breed, the program prioritizes natives, though not exclusively. Lombardoni noted that people apply different standards for what counts as native, whether a species must grow in their county, state, or region. He favors the regional view, reasoning that plants do not observe artificial borders between counties or states, particularly where those borders lack physical barriers that would keep plants from spreading.
Screening exotic genera for invasive potential
If an exotic genus is considered for breeding, the program examines two factors tied to seed reproduction that can contribute to invasive potential. The first is fecundity, or how much seed a plant produces; the second is dispersal, or how readily those seeds spread, whether a few feet or much farther. In some cases vegetative spread should also be weighed, since a species may expand through rhizomes, stolons, suckers, or other non-seed means. Lombardoni pointed to kudzu (Pueraria montana) as an extreme reminder of what can happen when a plant's ability to spread is underestimated.
Focusing on niche genera
Because the breeding program is small and has limited resources, Lombardoni said it cannot compete head-to-head with larger commercial programs. Even if it could, many mainstream genera are already saturated with dozens or even hundreds of cultivars on the market. He questioned whether another Echinacea or Hosta is needed when comparatively esoteric genera still hold untapped potential.
Traits the program avoids
Traits of interest vary widely by genus, so Lombardoni said it is easier to describe what the program does not pursue. The most prominent example is highly compact cultivars, which have proliferated in industry breeding over the past decade or two because they look good in pots and ship efficiently. While he would not rule out releasing a compact cultivar should a promising selection arise, he said this is not something he actively seeks. He clarified that compact in this context means roughly 30 inches or shorter in height, and that a 4-foot cultivar bred from a species normally 5 or 6 feet tall would not strike him as very compact. There is a difference, he said, between reining in the size of an unruly species and releasing a cultivar half or less the height of the species it came from.
A second trait the program avoids is sterility, which in ornamental horticulture can appear as double flowers. In such cases additional petals may replace the pistils and/or stamens, potentially reducing available pollen or making other floral resources less accessible to pollinators. More broadly, Lombardoni said the program does not seek cultivars with traits that hinder their ecological function.
Plans to study pollinator visitation
Pollinator support matters to many home gardeners, and Lombardoni said the program hopes to collaborate with the Garden's Science Department, which is partnered with Northwestern University, to study pollinator visitation to its breeding selections and compare their performance with straight species. Such work could help clarify how the abundance and diversity of pollinator visitation differ between the two.
A case in point: Eutrochium maculatum 'Summer Snow'
One cultivar that illustrates these priorities is Eutrochium maculatum 'Summer Snow', released about 10 years ago. It was bred from germplasm collected roughly 90 miles from the Garden. Although that germplasm came from three counties away, Lombardoni still considers it a native selection because its species is also native to the Garden's own county. At 5 feet tall, the plant is not significantly shorter than the straight species, and its highly upright stems bear white flowers that support pollinators from mid- to late summer.
Why nonprofit status matters
Aesthetics are understandably a major consideration when breeding perennials for the commercial market, especially how a plant looks in a pot, and ecological function may not always receive the same emphasis. As a nonprofit, Lombardoni said the program is not seeking to release a certain number of cultivars each year or to maximize sales of each one. That lack of pressure, he said, allows the Garden to breed perennials differently from many commercial programs. His hope is that gardens will not someday consist entirely of perennials 2 feet or shorter.
