A new study has examined whether four commercial natural pigments can withstand the melt processing used to colour two biodegradable polymers, polylactic acid (PLA) and polybutylene succinate (PBS), without losing their colour or undermining the materials' flow and mechanical behaviour.
The work, published as "Sustainability in the Development of Natural Pigment-Based Colour Masterbatches and Their Application in Biopolymers," used blue spirulina, yellow curcumin, red beetroot and green chlorophyllin. Each pigment was compounded with PLA and PBS into colour masterbatches on a twin-screw extruder, then diluted into the matching polymer at 2, 4 and 6 wt% and injection moulded into test specimens. The masterbatch formulation also contained titanium dioxide, calcium carbonate and stearic acid, added to support UV protection, dispersion and processing.
Thermal window sets the limits
Heat is the central constraint. Thermogravimetric analysis put degradation onset at about 229 °C for spirulina, 244 °C for curcumin, 258 °C for chlorophyllin and 267 °C for beetroot, all below the degradation temperatures of PLA and PBS. The researchers therefore chose extrusion profiles that melted each polymer while limiting the pigments' thermal exposure: 145 °C for PBS and 190 °C for PLA, with the twin-screw extruder running at 65 rpm and a feed rate of 2 kg/h.
Most pigment–polymer pairs processed successfully, but spirulina was the clear exception. In PLA it lost its characteristic blue colour, so a blue PLA masterbatch could not be produced. PBS, processed at the lower temperature, retained enough pigment stability for compounding. The result, the authors note, shows that pigment compatibility depends strongly on the thermal requirements of the polymer matrix rather than on the colorant alone.
Flow and mechanical performance largely preserved
Rheologically, the pigments caused only limited change. Melt flow rate fell slightly after incorporation, indicating a modest rise in melt viscosity. Neat PLA measured about 50 g/10 min, and its natural-pigment masterbatches stayed close to that figure; PBS showed a similarly small reduction. For compounders, the practical point is that conventional twin-screw compounding and injection moulding handled most formulations without major changes to screw design, pressure settings or moulding conditions.
Tensile and impact tests over the 2–6 wt% range showed no significant overall losses. PLA began at a Young's modulus of about 1710 MPa and tensile strength of 65.6 MPa, while PBS began at about 392 MPa and 34.5 MPa; coloured formulations remained near those baselines. Impact strength stayed in a similar range, although individual pigments produced some variation.
Colour fastness is the remaining obstacle
Successful extrusion did not guarantee durable colour. After 50 hours of xenon-lamp exposure, most formulations exceeded a colour difference of ΔE* = 2, a change the study describes as visually perceptible. The main exception was PLA containing 2 wt% green chlorophyllin masterbatch, which showed the highest photostability.
The study therefore identifies UV stability as the largest barrier to wider use. Packaging, consumer products, agricultural parts and outdoor applications may need additional stabilisation, protective coatings or pigment modification before natural colors can compete with conventional systems over long service periods.
Lower carbon footprint, with caveats
Under the study's assumptions, the environmental comparison favoured the natural colorants. One kilogram of curcumin pigment generated about 0.04 kg CO2-eq, against 18.65 kg CO2-eq for the inorganic green reference pigment. The natural-pigment masterbatches also consumed less electricity during extrusion and pelletising.
The researchers conclude that several natural colorants can be compounded into PLA and PBS on conventional equipment with limited effect on melt viscosity and mechanical performance, but that lightfastness and thermal stability still require development. Future work, they suggest, should focus on colour stability during processing and subsequent service exposure.
