UK regulators have moved to address a shortage of packaging recycling evidence after tighter accreditation and enforcement rules reduced the availability of Packaging Waste Recycling Notes (PRNs) and Packaging Waste Export Recycling Notes (PERNs). Regulatory Position Statements issued on 9 October are intended to prevent some producers and compliance schemes from struggling to demonstrate compliance with their 2026 recycling obligations.
Under the position statements, regulators will not normally take enforcement action for plastic, steel and wood where businesses meet at least 83% of the statutory plastic recycling obligation, 92% of the steel obligation and 90% of the wood obligation. Full compliance remains required for all other packaging materials.
Changes to the evidence market
The Foodservice Packaging Association (FPA) said the intervention followed changes introduced during 2026 to strengthen the integrity of the PRN/PERN system. These included tighter accreditation requirements for reprocessors and exporters, a new fit-and-proper-person test, increased enforcement activity, and revised export rules under which PERNs can be issued only after packaging waste reaches an overseas reprocessing facility.
Defra said those measures had improved transparency and helped address fraud and error, but had also reduced the number of accredited reprocessors and exporters and increased the time needed to issue PERNs, constraining the supply of recycling evidence.
Relief does not alter statutory duties
The Environment Agency's Regulatory Position Statement 383 states that statutory recycling obligations have not been amended. Businesses that satisfy the RPS conditions will normally avoid enforcement action for missing the original targets in the three affected materials, but Certificates of Compliance will still record non-compliance where statutory obligations have not been met, even if the reduced RPS thresholds are satisfied.
Businesses relying on the RPS must retain supporting records for five years, meet their full obligations for other packaging materials and continue to comply with all other applicable requirements. The intervention applies only to the 2026 compliance year.
2027 targets under review
Defra described the circumstances as exceptional and committed to reviewing recycling targets for 2027. It said the review would take account of factors including the introduction of deposit return schemes (DRS) and the delayed mandatory kerbside collection of plastic film in England.
The FPA said the impact of DRS would be particularly significant. Under current arrangements, in-scope PET plastic bottles and aluminium and steel drinks cans collected through DRS will no longer generate PRNs or PERNs. That means valuable, relatively high-quality material will be removed from the existing recycling evidence market, even though it will continue to be recycled through the new scheme. Unless recycling targets and obligations properly reflect the change, producers could face further difficulty securing enough evidence to demonstrate compliance.
The delayed introduction of mandatory kerbside collections for plastic film in England, now scheduled for April 2030, adds another consideration when assessing the volume of material likely to be available for recycling and for generating PRNs. Longer-term reform of the PRN/PERN system also remains under consideration following consultation on measures intended to improve transparency, reduce fraud and create a more level playing field between UK reprocessors and exporters.
FPA calls for fundamental examination
The FPA said the need for regulators to intervene to prevent enforcement action raised serious concerns about how the system is managed and how future targets are set.
The association said it fully supported efforts to eliminate fraud and error, adding that stronger accreditation, more rigorous verification and greater transparency were essential to maintaining confidence. But it argued that if improving the integrity of recycling evidence exposes a substantial shortfall in availability, that should prompt a fundamental examination of the assumptions behind recycling targets.
The FPA also drew a distinction between relief from enforcement and resolution of the underlying compliance problem. It noted that statutory obligations remain unchanged and that producers meeting the reduced thresholds may still have non-compliance recorded against them, and said businesses needed clarity about the practical implications.
According to the FPA, the review of 2027 targets must go beyond adjusting percentages. It should establish whether targets are supported by demonstrable domestic and overseas recycling capacity and reliable evidence supply, account for the introduction of DRS in October 2027 and reflect the delayed plastic-film collections. The FPA said those assessments should be transparent and open to industry scrutiny.
The association added that producers were already facing financial and administrative pressures from the wider packaging reform programme and should not also be exposed to unpredictable compliance costs caused by a mismatch between regulatory obligations and the evidence market. It said the test of the government's response would be whether it delivers a more stable, credible and achievable system for 2027 and beyond.
